Court of Appeals 2nd Circuit

The 2nd Circuit Court is a federal-level court of appeals based in New York City with jurisdiction over districts that include all of Connecticut, Vermont, and all four sectors of New York state.

Thirteen justices occupy the bench in the 2nd Circuit, with an additional nine serving as senior justices. The judges are called Title III because their positions were created by the Constitution. Federal judges are appointed by the President, approved by Congress and may occupy their position on the court for life. Magistrate judges assist the circuit judges but their terms may vary.

In addition to the 12 regional appellate courts to which it belongs there is one Federal Circuit Court of Appeals that hears certain cases involving trade, patents, and similar issues. In federal appeals courts, judges hear cases and render decisions as the jury system is not used.

At the federal level the circuit or appellate courts have jurisdiction over the 94 U.S. District Courts that are within their regions. The 2nd Circuit was created in 1891, gradually expanding to its current complement of judges and functions.

Second Circuit Court Process

The 2nd Circuit began 2014 with about 3,600 total cases before it, 770 of which were criminal cases and over 1,000 administrative appeals, which are described in court documents as mainly immigration cases. Private civil cases account for another 1,000 or more.

The Supreme Court has recently affirmed more of the 2nd Circuit’s cases than it has reversed, giving the court a better-than-average 33 percent reversal rate (the 1st Circuit currently has a 50 percent reversal rate, the 9th Circuit has an 87 percent reversal rate).

Federal district courts within the 2nd Circuit handle cases that concern felonies, those which seek penalties or damages of $75,000 or more, and cases involving persons from more than one state or country (as in a class action lawsuit). The 2nd Circuit court seats a panel of judges to hear federal district court decisions from within its jurisdiction that are appealed.

Second Circuit Court Notable Decisions

The Southern District Court of New York (encompassing several counties surrounding Manhattan) has heard cases stemming from the sinking of the Titanic and financial wrongdoing cases against Bernard Madoff, Ivan Boesky and Michael Milken, hotelier Leona Helmsley and insider trading charges against house-and-home media mogul Martha Stewart.

Among the infamous and unusual cases that have been before the Southern District Court of New York and the 2nd Circuit court is New England Patriots football quarterback Tom Brady’s appeal of a penalty he was assessed by the National Football League. In 2013 Brady was accused of purposely deflating footballs to get a better grip on them for more accurate passes and making the balls easier for players to hold onto while running. The NFL assessed a 4-game suspension for the star player after an investigation, but Brady took the matter to court because NFL Commissioner Roger Goodell acted as sole hearing officer for the incident. A judge threw out the suspension, but the 2nd Circuit reversed that decision, upholding the penalty. Brady then appealed the court’s ruling on the suspension. A decision is expected from the court at any time.